Audiobook Review: Swan Song by Robert McCammon

22 11 2011

Swan Song by Robert McCammon

Read by Tom Stechshulte

Audible, Inc.

Length: 34 Hrs 22 Mins

Genre: Post Apocalyptic Dark Fantasy

Quick Thoughts: While Swan Song is one of my favorite all time books, and a must read for fans of Post Apocalyptic fiction and Dark Fantasy, I found the experience of it much more rewarding than remembered. Maybe it’s being older, or experiencing it as an audiobook, but revisiting this world only made me love it more.

Grade: A

If I had to pick two novels that truly defined my teenage years and set the framework for what kind of reader the adult me would become, the first of those books would be Stephen King’s The Stand and the second, Robert McCammon’s nuclear post apocalyptic dark fantasy, Swan Song. Swan Song doesn’t get the mainstream hype that The Stand does, but by true hardcore fans of Post Apocalyptic novels, it is considered a classic to rival and for some even surpass Stephen King’s plague opus. I first read Swan Song when I was 15 and since have read the book completely through four more times. Swan Song was one of the books I always kept on my nightstand, and occasionally would pick it up to relive a favorite passage. It is quite hard for me to sit down and write a review for a book that I just truly love. So, this will be less of a review, and more of a sharing of my experience reliving the events of this novel in a different format. I really don’t listen to many novels that I have already read, this year my only “relistens” were the Wild Cards anthology and Rothfuss’ The Name of the Wind. Yet, when I found out that Swan Song was coming to audio, it was a given that I would be listening to it as soon as it was released.

One of the reasons that audiobooks work so well it that stories are meant to be told, and the best books, to be read aloud. Experiencing Swan Song in audio form took a story I knew so well, and gave it a new spin, letting me relive it, yet opening things up to me that I never realized was there before. Yes, the same tales were there, the same characters did the same things, but in listening, the prose and poetry of McCammon’s world took on a whole new beauty. I have read many times of Sister Creep and her fantasies, of being chased by fire through the tunnels of New York City, yet, in audiobook form the words were crisper and the rhythms more discernable. There are so many moments in this novel that have stuck with me for years, that I even thought of them in terms not in the book, like Paul and his radio roulette, and Josh and his fist breaking through the scorched earth. I have been haunted and thrilled by these images. Yet, I think other things affected me more this time, McCammon’s descriptions of the initial attacks, the changing relationship between Swan and her protector cum father figure Josh invoked truly emotional responses that surprised me. I spent more time reliving the relationships then reveling in the action. I even found more depth of character in the stories of various antagonists like Colonel Macklin and Roland.  While Swan Song is one of my favorite all time books, and a must read for fans of Post Apocalyptic fiction and Dark Fantasy, I found the experience of it much more rewarding than remembered. Maybe it’s being older, or experiencing it as an audiobook, but revisiting this world only made me love it more.

I have to hand it to the narrator Tom Stechshulte. I definitely had voices and preconceptions of the characters in my head and I knew, just knew I would be disappointed when I heard his versions of the character voices. Yet, for the most part, he found the perfect tones for characters. Yes, there was a bit of a strange feeling hearing some of these characters voiced, especially Sister, yet, I really grew to enjoy his various takes on the characters. What really impressed me with Stechshulte’s reading was how he captured the timing and rhythms of McCammon’s writing, showing me poetry where I didn’t realize it existed. I did have a few technical and peevish issues at times. Occasionally there was a slight background buzz in the production and some distracting extraneous mouth sounds, but most of it got smoothed out as the audiobook progressed. Any little peevish issues I had in no way took away from the overall enjoyment of the audiobook production. I just hope that this title is successful enough to bring other classic McCammon titles into the audiobook world, especially The Wolf’s Hour and Mystery Walk, as well as his more recent Matthew Corbett series.



7 responses

22 11 2011

I’ll definitely be picking this up sooner or later – haven’t ever read it, somehow, along the way it’s one I always overlooked.

I loved Stechschulte’s narration of Journal of a UFO Investigator, and can definitely imagine him really doing a good job with this type of book.

22 11 2011
Spotlight on the Wordpress Book Bloggers! « Randomize ME

[…] The Guilded Earlobe – He who has ears let him hear… audiobooks by theguildedearlobe – “Audiobook Review: Swan Song by Robert McCammon“ […]

22 11 2011
Linda Cravinho

I am reading Swan Song for the 3rd time, this time on my Kindle:) I first read this book on a camping trip with a friend and they would put it down and I would pick it up… ALL WEEKEND:) I don’t think we said more than a few words to each other the entire trip. That was in my early 20’s… read it again in my 30’s and now in my 40’s, my Mom has read it, my son, my nephew and as many others as I can talk into reading such a HUGE paperback. It is a story you will never forget! I met a little girl once, she was about 4… out of the blue she walked right up to me and introduced herself to me a Swan. I about fell over! She had been named after the book, I found her parents and they said she will walk up to random people and introduce herself… weird.

23 11 2011
joyce olsen

I have read Swan Song so many times and lent it to so many people that it is almost in tatters though still readable. Will have to try the Audio version one of these days.

15 12 2011
My Top 20 Audiobooks of 2011 « The Guilded Earlobe

[…] My Review […]

28 05 2012

I like your review but I have always found Swan Song a fluffy read compared to the Stand and, worse, without the engrossing political nuances of the latter. And the characters were drawn as if to help the readers symphatize with them, glossing over many bad features of them for the sake of creating nice fellows, unlike the Stand’s characters who you may love and hate easily at the same time, Nadine and Frann being prime examples. I read Swan Song once and it is enough for me, there are not so many depths into it that merit another read unlike the Stand, which after the fourth read still makes you put down the book and chew on what you have read and its ramifications.

19 10 2012
2011 in review, 2 of 4: What I missed. | The AudioBookaneers

[…] Song by Robert McCammon — The Guilded Earlobe loves this novel and the new audiobook, and narrator Stechschulte is one of my […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: