Audiobook Review: Ghost Story by Jim Butcher

1 08 2011

Ghost Story by Jim Butcher (The Dresden Files, Book 13)

By Jim Butcher

Read by John Glover

Penguin Audiobooks

Genre: Fantasy

Quick Thoughts: While not the best Dresden File novel, Ghost Story is a novel full of heart and packed with so many of great moments, some funny, some surprising and many utterly heart breaking.

Grade: A-

Special Note: While I strive to write reviews that are free of spoilers for both the book, and previous editions of the series, I find that it is impossible to write a good review of Ghost Story without revealing major plot elements of the previous Dresden Files novel Changes. If you have not read Changes, or any of the previous editions of the Dresden Files, I would avoid reading the first two paragraphs of this review. If you are here simply to find out my take on John Glover’s narration, feel free to read the final paragraph without fear of spoilers.  Also, do not worry, I will not be spoiling any parts of Ghost Story, just previous novels.

Have you ever watched a TV show, where there is a big jump in time from one season to the next, and while all the characters are there, and still are familiar at their core level, but something about them seems just a bit off, as if we missed something big in their lives. That is the feeling I had while reading Ghost Story, the 13th Book in the Dresden Files series. The previous title in the series Changes, was easily my favorite in the series, but beyond personal taste it was also the most shattering world changing book in a series I have read. Changes was such an apt title, because the decisions and actions that take place during that book will drastically affect the rest of the series. Not only has Harry discovered that he has a daughter, and that she was being held hostage, but each step he takes in her rescue pulls him further down a path he never wanted. Each decision was more terrible than the next, from agreeing to become Mab’s Winter’s Knight, to his murder of his daughters mother Susan Rodriguez and utterly annihilating the Red Court Vampires. These decisions will forever alter the world of Butcher’s making. Even small decisions like involving his sensitive apprentice Molly is an all out battle against evil has created major ripples in Harry’s world. Yet, the most devastating moment, the crack of a rifle, Harry’s body falling into the cold depths of Lake Michigan, has put us readers down a path that we never expected.

Harry Dresden may possibly be my favorite literary character. Now, I am not saying The Dresden Files books are my all time favorite, each has its own highs and lows, but as a character, Harry is the epitome of what I like in a first person narrator. So, I went into Ghost Story a bit hesitant. How will non-breathing Harry stand up to the Harry many of us have come to love? So, within the first few minute when Harry throws out a Barry Manillo/hell joke, and shows off his usual smartass comments and self deprecating humor, I began to feel more comfortable. Yet that comfort began to wane as Harry begins to see the world he left, and the way the people close to him have changed since his death, and his inability to do anything about it. This is the true reality he must face, that the people he left behind are changed, some for the good and some for the heartbreakingly bad. Ghost Story is a story of unintended consequences. Sure, like many other Dresden tales it is full of action, and mystery, and is a morality tale of how good men and women often blur the line between good and evil to achieve their goals.  Yet what truly sets it apart from other additions in the series is how decisions, no matter how well intended, can set off a unforeseen chain of events. There are some great moments in this novel, characters who we would never expect becoming heroes, while others who seem so strong pulled down by paranoia, grief and the necessities of the changed world. Ghost Story is not my favorite of The Dresden Files, I felt certain parts of the plot were muddled, and often unsatisfactorily explored, yet, any flaws in the plotting are made up for by the heart of the novel. If you are a Dresden fan, you cannot help to be moved by this novel and Harry’s journey from his death to his fate.

Now, onto the controversial element of this audiobook. If you haven’t heard, longtime Dresden narrator and fan favorite James Marsters was unavailable to read Ghost Story. Instead of further delaying the release date, actor John Glover was brought in to narrate the audiobook instead. . The change of narrator is often controversial, but it is especially tough for first person tales. The narrator must be the voice of the character, encompassing his inner and external dialogue. Glover had big shoes to fill. Marsters brought certain affectations to the voice of Dresden, his sighs and pacing when delivering one of Dresden’s patented smart ass remarks that would be near impossible to emulate. I think Glover did a decent job capturing Dresden’s voice. After getting use to his voice, I was rarely pulled out of the story because of his narration. There were some moments, especially when Glover would change from inner to external dialogue, where his higher tones in his voice would momentarily remind me of the new narrator, but as the book progressed these moments came less and less. Where I thought Glover did an amazing job was the voicing of the peripheral characters. His vocalizations of characters like Bob and Butters seemed so in line with what Marsters did, I can’t help but think Glover spent some time listening to Marster’s interpretation. My suggestion to fans of The Dresden Files audiobooks, go into Glover’s reading with an open mind and a willingness to give it some time, and I think you will, at the very least be able to tolerate his reading, or perhaps, like me, enjoy it. Remember, liking Glover’s reading does not mean you are being disloyal to James Marsters. I think he would want you to like it.

About these ads

Actions

Information

2 responses

10 08 2011
Dresden Disappointment – Part 1 « Stevi's Habitat

[…] Audiobook Review: Ghost Story by Jim Butcher […]

9 11 2011
Arthur005

Sadly it is not about being disloyal to James Marsters no not that at all. It is about them betraying us by changing readers at the last minute so that no one could cancel their orders. So that they could have their money right away rather than choosing to wait a bit for Marsters to be free. I could understand if it was something they could never agree on but all they are will to tell us is the stupidest reason imaginable for changing readers.

We don’t want to Wait MONEY

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,560 other followers

%d bloggers like this: